Pages

Thursday, November 17, 2011

Bus fare ‘not fair’


Fee will mean fewer visits for Fort Williams, tour operators predict.


CAPE ELIZABETH — The Cape Elizabeth Town Council voted 5-2 Monday to begin assessing a fee on tour groups entering Fort Williams Park, starting with the 2012 season.
Although the move would seem counter to the wishes of residents, who in 2006 and 2010 voted overwhelmingly against implementing parking fees for all visitors, a majority of the council said those decisions do not apply to commercial entities.
“I can’t believe that a business, whether it’s a trolley company, a coach, or a tour operator, can listen to the debate that has gone on in this town about this subject for the last several years and not come forward and take the moral obligation that I believe they should take,” said Councilor James Walsh. “They’ve got to have some skin in the game. They’re taking this incredible asset that is world-known, and they are selling tours to what we’ve expended tax money on for years, and they are going to the bank with it.”
“We must drive revenue to support the park now and in the future,” agreed Councilor Frank Governali. “Costs will rise inevitably and we cannot continue to put that burden on Cape Elizabeth taxpayers forever.”
As might be expected, tour operators see the issue differently.
“The implication I leave here with tonight is that it’s their playground and they don’t want us here,” said Jeanne McGurn, of Maine Tour Connecton, after the vote.
Council Chairman David Sherman expressed a similar view.
“I think this all boils down to the fact that some people in town just don’t like the buses,” he said.
“This fee is not fair,” said cruise ship director Greg Gordon. “In fact, it’s discriminatory. We’d support a fee of some kind, but it’s got to be fair and equitable, and charged to everyone.”
“They’re biting the hand that feeds them,” said McGurn. “I mean, we bring people there to spend money.”
The specter of diminished returns at the Portland Head Light gift shop was raised. McGurn and Gordon both predicted fewer visits to the park next year, and thus lower sales.
Town Manager Michael McGovern said the museum and gift shop at Portland Head Light grossed $500,000 in sales last year. However, net revenue after product costs, wages and other overhead amounts to just $70,000 “in a good year,” he said.
Next year, buses entering the park will have to pay $40 per trip, whether sent by a cruise ship or “arriving randomly.” Bus tours sent by nonprofit groups will be exempt from the fee. Meanwhile, trolleys that frequent the park will be assessed a $1,500 annual entrance fee.
According to Bill Nickerson, chairman of the Fort Williams Advisory Commission, three sight-seeing trolleys made regular runs to the park last year, while 784 buses passed through the gate. If that number holds true in 2012, the town will reap $35,860 in fees.
However, McGovern has said that after an as-yet-undetermined method of collecting the fee is put in place, actual revenue should be “about $30,000,” after factoring out administrative costs.
Any amount is fine with Betty Crane, who began the charge for bus fees last spring, in appearances before the Nickerson-led commission.
“We have to face the fact that we need some money,” she said Monday, following a trail of like-minded citizens to the public hearing podium – a stark contrast to last month’s council meeting, when Crane was the lone champion for bus fees among half a dozen dissenters.
“The buses have enjoyed the profits of coming here for years and $40 is practically nothing,” said Crane.
In May, when the fee structure was first presented to the council by Nickerson, Michael Foye, a tour guide for Intercruise Shoreside and Port Services, addressed the potential cost to his company, which shuttles about 23,000 people into Fort Williams Park on 525 bus trips during its 33-day season.
“If you do that math – $40 times 525 buses – it’s over $21,000,” he said. “This is a significant impact on us.”
Foye was not at Monday’s hearing, but several other tour operators were on hand, and none liked what they heard.
Both McGurn and Gregg Isherwood, owner of Custom Coach and Limousine, say they’ve already begun advertising next year’s tour packages. Because the new fee was not factored in, they will have to “eat it,” they say. Both join Gordon in complaining that no one from the town ever reached out to them for input when a fee was first being considered. As a result, all promise fewer visits next year.
“It won’t be a destination for us, I’ll offer it as a side item,” said Isherwood, who claims to send “200 to 300” buses into the park each year.
“Cruise ship passengers don’t really need to go to Portland Head Light,” he said. “They see it from the water coming in and going out.”
Sherman pointed out that visitors who arrive with the tour buses generally stay in the park just long enough to snap a picture of the lighthouse and dash into the gift shop. Bus exhaust aside, these tourists actually have less of an impact on the park that locals who get in free, he said, citing joggers, dog walkers and users of the various tennis courts and athletic fields.
Sherman also rebutted a point made by Councilor Sara Lennon, who predicted that tourists would be “delighted” to pay an extra dollar – assuming 40 passengers per bus – whether it is passed on by the tour operator or handed over on site.
“The idea that people from away can afford it, I think, as a justification, with all due respect, stinks,” he said.
Still, Sherman said his primary reason for weighing in against the bus fee was the previous public votes. Like the other dissenter, outgoing Councilor Anne Swift-Kayatta, he has voted for parking fees in the past, he said.
“I actually regret sending the last referendum out, because I clearly misjudged the town’s reaction,” he said. “But, with that vote in mind, I cannot in clear conscience vote in favor of fees. As I view it, it’s simply not fair to charge some people to access the park, but not all.”
Swift-Kayatta agreed. Although concerned that the fee would apply to older people who had no other means to access the park, she also felt most swayed by the previous votes.
“I remember the signs that said, ‘Keep the Park Free,’” she said, adding that no sign had continued, “Except for buses.”
Despite the objection of two senior councilors, the majority mood in the hall easily prevailed. Most citizens who spoke said tour groups should pay a fee because, unlike individual visitors, they bring people into the park for profit, even as Isherwood claimed, “We’re not exactly raking it in hand over fist.”
“I believe very strongly that, whatever that profit is, we need a piece of it to come back to us,” said Walsh.
“They should share our burden,” said resident Jessie Timberlake, “as they share our treasure.”


Smith named South Portland mayor


Patti Smith
SOUTH PORTLAND — On Monday, South Portland City Councilor Patti Smith got a nice nod of recognition to go along with her recent re-election victory – unanimous election as the city’s next mayor.

“I haven’t been here very long, I’ve only lived in Maine since 2004,” she said, her voice choking with emotion. “I just jumped into this arena without any history because I just love it here, and I have been made rich by all of the people here [on the council]. I just have a lot of respect for all of you.”

Smith, 47, lives with her partner of 18 years, environmental consultant Susan Chase. She works at Planet Dog in Portland, a worldwide maker, distributor and retailer of doggie treats, toys and accessories. Her official title is director of strategic initiatives, domestic sales, operations and human resources.

Smith won praise from all of her peers on the City Council, but especially her predecessor, Mayor Rosemarie De Angelis, who made the nomination.

“Patti Smith is an outstanding example of intelligence, of ethical standards and of vision,” said De Angelis. “I think she brings a great presence to the council.”

For her part, Smith said Tuesday that her primary goal is to not screw up a good thing.

“I’m just thrilled to be a part of this council,” she said. “I’ve been really impressed with how we’ve been able to get good things done. We’re not afraid to disagree, but we always do it in a respectful way and at the end of the day it’s a good, working team.”

An avid gardener and hiker, Smith said she will remain an advocate for South Portland’s open spaces, while also balancing school and service needs with the needs of taxpayers. “We want to cherish and preserve out small-town feel, and make sure people are able to afford to live here.”


Friday, November 11, 2011

Eddie Woodin: "People who give back have more fulfilling lives"


Eddie Woodin stands in front of the “Wall of Fame” he
 keeps at the offices of his Scarborough business, Woodin
& Co. Store Fixtures, where each photograph depicts one
of his charitable or spiritual successes. Woodin’s goal is
to inspire others of his generation to follow his example,
and to learn from his experiences.
SCARBOROUGH — Outside the Woodin & Co. Store Fixtures showroom on Gannett Drive in Scarborough stands a pole flying the American Flag. No surprise there, a lot of businesses like to sport their patriotism. But there also is another flag, one featuring a white field with a red Latin cross on a blue upper-hoist canton. It’s called, quite simply, the Christian Flag.
“I think,” says business owner Eddie Woodin, “that mine is the only business in the state of Maine with one of those.”
Woodin, 64, is about as charismatic as they come. A short man with a big heart and the winning smile of everybody’s favorite uncle, he instantly puts people at their ease. He’s unafraid to give tours of his shop in stocking feet, or to wear his Christianity on his sleeve.
Or even on a flagpole, as the case may be.
“My philosophy is, I only manage the business, God owns it,” he says, explaining the flag. “That’s been fundamental to it, and everything’s tended to work well.
“We give back a lot,” he adds, lowering his voice to a conspiratorial tone, as if God might hear him committing the sin of pride. “We give a lot in terms of time, money and encouragement.”
Woodin gives away his money as fast as he earns it – between $100,000 and $200,000 a year, he says. Scarborough’s Project GRACE, Maine Audubon, the Boy Scouts of America, the Southern Maine Agency on Aging and the Center for Wildlife, all have benefited from his generosity. In recent years, as the recession has put a crimp in company profits, Woodin has dipped into his own pocket, too.
Now, he’s hoping to teach others of his generation to practice the same philanthropy he’s made a way of life, starting from a time when his checks were more often of the $5 and $10 variety, “because that’s all I could afford at the time.”
Woodin is currently working on two books. One is about his faith-based philosophy of giving back, the second about “developing a fulfilling, rich life through a relationship with God.”
The former book has a finished draft Woodin plans to proof over the winter, and publish sometime next year, while also fleshing out the 14 chapters of its follow-up, now in outline form. The hope, he says, is to parlay those books into a speaking tour, through which he can inspire others of his generation to follow his example, and to learn from his experience – as a believer, a community booster and a board member of more than 30 service groups – as they cast about for thing to do during their retirement years.
“People who give back live longer and have more fulfilling lives,” he says, adding with an almost wistful air, “A philanthropy coach. I like that concept. I would like to do that.”
A lifelong devotee of The Word, Woodin was born again in 1988, but he’s had at least two additional turning points since then.
The first was in 1990, in a faraway hotel bed. As a VP for Pittsburg-based Child Store Fixtures International, Wooden spent a lot of time on the road. At one point, he woke up not being able to remember at first what city he was in.
“I was gone from home all the time and at that moment, I knew I was done. I had hit a wall,” he says. After two years of trying to limit himself to New England area calls, Woodin got a call of his own.
“God said to me, ‘It’s time to start a business,” he recalls, with a laugh. “I said in reply, “‘But what about my steady paycheck?’”
No matter. Unable to land a bank loan, Woodin founded his own company in 1992 with $20,000 he managed to scrape together, loading the rest on five personal credit cards.
“Today,” he says, “We’re a $6 million company.”
His is a “virtual business,” Woodin likes to say, explaining that rather than make fixtures himself, he places orders with manufactures (sadly, he admits, none in Maine) on behalf of his clients, some as big as Polo Ralph Lauren and Barnes & Noble’s college bookstore division.
Woodin credits his faith for his success, along with an unrelenting quest to put his profits to good use.
The second turning point came four years ago when Woodin approached staffers at Project GRACE, announcing that God had sent him to create a fuel-assistance fund.
“They were like . . . OK,” he laughs, imitating the way people might react to a man with two heads and one hat.
But Woodin soon won them over, not just with a $2,500 check, but with his infectious positivity.
“Anything and everything is possible,” he says, reciting his impromptu speech that day. “Dream big, God’s the dream-maker, and we can do this.”
Woodin’s dream was that Project GRACE could leverage his “challenge grant” into a $10,000 fuel fund. They collected $40,000.
The same was true at the Center for Wildlife, where Woodin’s $2,500 check grew to a $22,000 fund to rehabilitate injured owls back into the wild, once others caught his spirit.
Woodin puts as much time as money into his community service, if not more. Adding two books to a regimen that includes “floating” across denominations to attend church services from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. every Sunday, on top of running a multi-million dollar business, would surely tax the soul of most men. But Woodin simply shrugs it off. When the work is good work, he says with a smile, it hardly seems like work at all.
“Everyone toils,” says Woodin, “I just try to bring people together in good will, joy and energy.”

Thursday, November 10, 2011

New restaurant opens in place of Governor’s


SOUTH PORTLAND — Governor’s Restaurant, a 50-year old family chain based in Old Town, has closed its South Portland location Oct. 30 after 15 years, though the restaurant was almost immediately reopened under different ownership.

Now the new restaurant, which is featuring much the same fare as Governor’s and is line for a renovation, is in need of a name.

“Right now, were still searching for the perfect name,” Greg Goforth, general manager of the Merry Manor Best Western Inn, which houses the restaurant. “We’re just calling it the Merry Manor Restaurant right now. So, if anybody in the community has a good idea, please let us know.”

Goforth said he was notified “a few months ago” that Governor’s would not renew the lease on its franchise agreement.

“We ended up not being open for Sunday dinner, but we opened up the same as usual the next morning at 6:30,” he said. “Our primary concern was to service our existing [banquet] contracts. We kept a lot of the same staff that was here, so it really was quite seamless.”

The menu is much the same – with a bit more emphasis on steaks and seafood in addition the Governor’s comfort-food fare – and the 14-member crew will be familiar to regulars. Only “about four or five” people still on staff at the changeover chose not to remain, said Goforth, adding that most already had plans to transition out with the slower winter season.

Goforth said the new restaurant hopes to serve the community as well as hotel patrons. Owned by Bangor-based Lafayette Hotels, which operates 25 hotels in Maine, including the Augusta’s Senator Inn and the Holiday Inn by the Bay in Portland, the Merry Manor plans a $500,000 overhaul of its restaurant.

Goforth said that in addition to updating mechanical systems and renovating the dining room and banquet halls, the Merry Manor will put in large-screen TVs and a bar with several local beers on tap, in an effort to broaden its appeal as a neighborhood destination.

“It should be a really nice place to stop and have a beer on the way home from work,” said Goforth, predicting a summertime staff of 35 – slightly more than Governor’s peak numbers.

“I’m a little more ambitious,” said Goforth. “I think we’ll be busy. We’re really excited.”

“We both regret the closing of the restaurant and the effect it will have on staff and guests,” said Randy Wadleigh, Governor’s CEO. “But I’m grateful to the owners of the Merry Manor Inn who have offered to rehire all 32 Governor’s employees at the renovated facility.”

Wadleigh, son of founders Leith and Donna Wadleigh, said a decision was made to not renew the restaurant’s lease at the Merry Manor, located just off the Interstate 95 exit on Main Street.

“At this point, we’re more focused on the market north of Lewiston,” he said, Wednesday. “We’re interested in the Augusta and Ellsworth areas.”

Lafayette Hotels COO Peter Daigle said his company will continue its relationship with Governor’s at the Fireside Inn and Suites in Waterville. “We thank Governor’s for being a great tenant,” he said.

Wadleigh said Governor’s will honor gift cards and coupons purchased at the South Portland store at any of the chain’s five remaining locations, in Bangor, Lewiston, Old Town, Presque Isle and Waterville.


Impact fees set for Route 1 developments


SCARBOROUGH — The cost of commercial development in Scarborough has gone up, thanks to the implementation of impact fees tied to recent improvements at the intersection of Route 1 and Haigis Parkway.

At its most recent meeting, the Town Council unanimously approved a new ordinance that will assess a fee of $990 per trip generated through the rebuilt intersection by any new development requiring site plan or subdivision review by the Planning Board.

The fee is an attempt by the town to recover the $1.43 million it put into the project, less $120,000 in fees the town already has collected on development on Haigis Parkway prior to the creation of a formal ordinance, and a $300,000 discount based on the vehicle trips expected to be diverted to the intersection from another project further down Route 1, at Dunstan Corner.

“No one likes to impose additional fees, particularly in this economy,” said Town Manager Tom Hall. “But I think what this can do is have a developer assess for themselves what is the impact fee. As it is now, they are at the whim, in some cases, of the Planning Board and [the Maine Department of Transportation], and that’s an uncertain cost that’s not known until they are very deep into the development process.”

Harvey Rosenfeld, president of the Scarborough Economic Development Corp., said he agrees with that reasoning, noting in a recent interview that what developers like best is certainty.

“It’s a little hard to explain to people, but basically, being proactive with fees, rather than reactive, pays off in the long run,” he said.

Hall acknowledges that the new fee is “somewhat backwards” from how impact fees are generally assessed. The more common practice is to access a fee on development with the idea that growth puts a strain on a town’s recourses, forcing it to build or improve services and infrastructure. Scarborough has employed the use of such fees for more than two decades.

However, in this case, the town built out the infrastructure first and will access fees on development expected to make use of that project, until the debt on it has been retired.

“The intersection was sized in terms of lanes and capacity to accommodate new traffic on Route 1 and the Haigis Parkway, so this fee helps the town recover some those costs that can only benefit new development,” said Town Planner Dan Bacon.

While it may seem counterintuitive, Rosenfeld said developers actually like having to bear those costs, rather than having them spread across the entire tax base.

“Not everyone in economic development agrees with me on this, but when a development causes a need for public improvements, and those costs get paid by everybody in town, taxes go up,” he said. “One reason Scarborough has a low tax rates is that they’ve had impact fees for a long time. A low tax rate is necessary for economic development. In the long term, it really pays off for everyone.”

Developers, Rosenfeld said, would rather deal with a fixed fee they can count on and a generally low tax rate, as opposed to no fees and a property tax rate that could jump all over the place.

”It’s either an up-front fee or a long-term fee you have no control over,” he explained.

And just as those fixed fees are eliminated once the town recoups construction costs, impact fees can go down over time. That’s the case in Dunstan Corner, which has been subject to an impact fee since 2006. The council is slated to vote on an amendment to that fee at its next meeting, based on recent and planned improvements in that area.

Those plans include closing the end of Payne Road and turning it into what Hall calls a “glorified driveway” for the Dunstan School Restaurant. A new road will be built on the North side of the school to connect Route 1 to Payne Road. That serves the duel purpose of stretching out two adjacent intersections in that area, where traffic tends to back up through the second stop light, as, town planners hope, diverting about 20 percent of the traffic now using Payne Road to Haigis Parkway, because some people are expected to find the new configuration too difficult to deal with.

The 2006 Dunstan impact fee attempted to collect 25 percent of the town’s $6 million in construction costs. The new fee demands 25 percent of the more recent $3.45 million project, plus $300,000 as the calculated cost of diverting traffic to Haigis Parkway and the $270,000 the town spent to buy the Scarborough Signs property, where the new road will go.

That results in a new impact fee of $1,402 per trip generated, versus the previous fee of $1,471.