Pages

Thursday, November 10, 2011

Extinguished: Following the lead of other communities, Scarborough now favors a fireworks ban


SCARBOROUGH — A common complaint about consumer fireworks, set to be decriminalized Jan. 1, is that they could go off in any direction.

The same might be said of Scarborough’s reaction to the new law.

After a Sept. 7 consensus vote against passing local restrictions, the Town Council last week reversed course, voting 5-2 at its most recent meeting to call for a public hearing on an ordinance banning the sale and use of consumer fireworks within town limits. However, that hearing is slated for Nov. 16 and the final vote, to be held the same night, could tip the town back to a laissez faire approach, depending on the result of Tuesday’s municipal elections, which occurred after The Current’s deadline. [For election coverage, go online to www.keepmecurrent.com.]

Of the five councilors who voted in favor of the fireworks ban at its first reading, two –Ron Ahlquist (up for re-election) and Judith Roy – said they did so primarily to give the public a chance to “have its say.” Of the three who expressed strong support for the ban, one – Michael Wood – was serving at his last meeting.

It’s also worth noting that Scarborough is one of the few communities where the fire chief is not beating the drum to enact a ban, at least not publicly. Chief Michael Thurlow says that while he is “personally opposed” to the legalization of consumer fireworks, he could not find a compelling reason to oppose them on a professional basis.

“Scarborough is trying to be a proactive business community and our official public position is that the state law took care of most of our concerns – such as, they [fireworks] can’t be set up on the beaches, they can’t be shot off by kids – so, we did not oppose it as public safety officials,” he said, following last week’s council meeting.

“We firmly believe that this is the policy board of the town,” said Thurlow, gesturing toward the council table. “It’s not my opinion that matters.”

Other chiefs, however, have been lining up to oppose the new law ever since Gov. Paul LePage laid his signature to it July 1. Since then, cities and towns across southern Maine have fairly raced to exercise an out written into the enabling legislation, which says municipalities may enact local restrictions, up to and including an outright ban on sale and use, if not possession, of fireworks.

REGIONAL REACTION

Portland was the first to do so on Sept. 19. South Portland followed suit Oct. 17. The Cape Elizabeth Town Council will conduct a final vote Nov. 14. In each case, the local fire chief, often with a chief of police at his side, has spoken in favor of outlawing the sale and use of any firework more powerful than the traditional “sparkler.”

Although cities and towns cannot outlaw simple possession, some have inched right up to the line, making it a crime to have the soon-to-be legal product “with the intent” to either sell it or set it off.

“Essentially, if we come across people who have them in their pocket, or on their person, and we’re investigating a complaint of fireworks being used in that area, that’s usually where were at,” explained South Portland Police Chief Ed Googins, in advance of the city vote.

In other words, he said, in South Portland, possession is grounds for prosecution, under the right circumstances.

The drive to outlaw fireworks in South Portland went up as straight and true as any skyrocket. The same could be said of Cape Elizabeth, where Councilor James Walsh admitted the ordinance committee didn’t wait for a Mother-May-I to take the first step.

“We took it upon ourselves without direction from the Town Council because we felt this needed to be addressed,” he said at first reading of the banning ordinance Oct. 12. 

SCARBOROUGH DEBATES

But in Scarborough, the initial reaction tended toward a minimalist approach. With input from Thurlow and Police Chief Robert Moulton, Hall advised against a local ban when broaching the issue with councilors for the first time. The strongest measure he suggested was the addition of a sprinkler-system requirement to local zoning rules, for any building, of any size, set up to sell fireworks.

That changed less than a week later at an ordinance committee meeting, when Chairwoman Carol Rancourt questioned the wisdom of letting state law stand. Her primary concern seemed to be that, while fireworks use would be limited to private property, they could be shot off any day of the year from 9 a.m. to 10 p.m. On July 4 and Dec. 31, the days one might ordinarily expect to hear the bang and pop of celebratory explosions, use is permitted until 12:30 the following morning.

“If we’re going to allow fireworks 24/7, then I’m going to let my dog bark 24/7,” she joked.

Meanwhile, Councilor Karen D’Andrea came to the meeting prepared, with multiple copies of the ordinance Portland had adopted. That resulted in a 180-degree shift in policy and sent a ban to the council over the objection of the third committee member, Jessica Holbrook.

Like Portland’s ordinance, the draft to be discussed in Scarborough Nov. 16 defines “consumer fireworks” by referring to Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Under wording set out by the U.S. Department of Transportation, it means, "explosives that present a minor explosion hazard [in which] the explosive effects are largely confined to the package and no projection of fragments of appreciable size or range is to be expected.”

Under Maine law, consumer fireworks may not include any “missile” products, such as bottle rockets, skyrockets and aerial spinners.

Dan Peart, director of showroom operations for Ohio-based Phantom Fireworks, which already has looked into opening up shop in Scarborough, said local officials “grossly misunderstand” the product.

“A consumer firework does not explode,” he said in a recent interview. “Chemically, it burns. You could take several consumer fireworks, put them in a Dixie cup, and at worst you’d flip the cup.”

Calling Maine’s new law “the Cadillac of fireworks legislation,” Peart pointed out that it does not legalize the aerial fireworks most people are familiar with from Independence Day celebrations, nor the infamous M-80 noisemaker.

So-called “cherry bombs” remain illegal, and should stay so, Peart said, comparing the 3 grams of explosive power in an M-80 to the 50 milliliters in a typical consumer firework by calling it the difference “between two shakes of salt, and the entire shaker.”

The distinction appeared lost on many Scarborough councilors, however, who cited the dangers posed by fireworks of any kind.

“I think it’s pretty common to know that fireworks are dangerous,” said D’Andrea. “Of all fireworks accidents and injuries, 40 percent are kids, who lose a hand, a finger, get an eye shot out. Certainly, we don’t want to add to those statistics in Scarborough.

“The U.S. Fire Administration says the safest way to enjoy fireworks is to let the professionals do it,” she added, saying that the shore side of Interstate 95 is too populated, and the inland side often too dry to expect legalization of fireworks to pass free of incident.

“I grew up in a world were we had fireworks,” countered Ahlquist. “We set them off and I don’t’ remember anyone getting hurt. I don’t remember anybody burning anybody’s house down.”

“It was a little while ago when you were a kid,” quipped Roy. “There were a lot less people in town then, and a lot less developments.”

D’Andrea, noting that Portland and South Portland have already banned consumer fireworks and Cape Elizabeth is posed to do so, while Old Orchard Beach, Gorham and Westbrook are all considering bans, or, in the latter case, restrictions.

“Frankly, for us to not ban would make us poor neighbors in many ways,” she said. “People would come here to buy fireworks and then go back to their town. Scarborough could be perceived as a real problem in all of this.”

“As far as other towns around us dictating what were going to do, I get a little defensive about that,” said Ahlquist. “I don’t think people will be mobbing into Scarborough.”
Councilor Richard Sullivan, a Portland firefighter, said he would not support an outright ban.
“Let’s see what happens,” he said. “To jump on the bandwagon right now, I don’t think that’s necessary.”




A CLOSER LOOK
The following cities and towns are among those that have enacted or are considering bans on consumer fireworks, which become legal to purchase, possess and use in Maine on Jan. 1. The decriminalization bill, signed into law by Gov. LePage in July, allows municipalities to pass local restrictions.

Ban on sale/use adopted: Portland (Sept. 19, City Council 9-0), South Portland (Oct. 17, City Council 7-0), North Yarmouth (Oct. 18, Town Meeting 21-8), Bangor (Oct. 24, City Council), and Lewiston (Nov. 1, City Council 5-2)

Vote on ban scheduled: Cape Elizabeth (Nov. 14, public hearing/council vote), Scarborough (Nov. 16, 
public hearing/council vote), Wiscasset (Dec. 13, referendum vote)

Ban rejected, restrictions enacted: Westbrook (Nov. 7)        

Ban ordinance tabled: (Augusta, Nov. 3)

Others considering bans: Bath, Belfast, Brunswick (Nov. 7 first reading), Falmouth, Farmingdale, Gorham (in committee), Old Orchard Beach, Orono, Paris, Waterboro, Windham (in committee) 

          

‘We lost a lot of men’ — Q&A with Earle A. Howard Sr.


A South Portland war hero reflects on the Battle of the Bulge, freeing POWs, and working at the same business for 66 years and counting.



Seated in front of a few of the medals he earned for service
in World War II, Earle Howard Sr., 87, of South Portland,
shows the “absolutely beautiful” letter written to his wife,
Virginia, by an Australian soldier he’d freed from a prisoner-
of-war camp, to advise that her husband was alive and well. 
SOUTH PORTLAND — When soldiers and those in solidarity with them gather for a candlelight vigil in Mill Creek Park Nov. 11, South Portland’s Earle A. Howard Sr. probably won’t be there. The 87-year-old says his legs trouble him too much now to stand for very long. But he’ll be there in spirit, he says, and few, it seems, have a spirit as strong as his.

As a young man, Howard worked in the South Portland yards where the Liberty Ships were built. He then rode one of those vessels across the English Channel to take part in the D-Day invasion. From there he fought his way across Europe with the 2nd Infantry Division, seeing action in Normandy, the Rhineland, Northern France, the Ardennes Forest, the Battle of the Bulge and Central Europe, earning 14 medals along the way.

Upon returning home in 1945, Howard landed a job with Wigon Office Supply, in Portland, for whom he continues to work to this day. Howard and his wife, Virginia, had three children and were married 56 years, until she died in 1999.

“I feel I am very lucky,” he said. “I’ve had one job all my life and one girl all my life.  I thought that was pretty good.”

Q: Where were you born and raised?

A: I was born in Providence, Rhode Island, but I came up here when I was just two weeks old to Munjoy Hill.

Q: Why did you join the service?

A: Uncle Sam called me, on Nov. 3, 1943. I had been working in the South Portland shipyard for two years. When I got word from the draft board I went down and said, “I don’t mind going into the service, but my wife is five months pregnant and I sure would like to see the baby before I go away.”

Q: What did they say to that?

A: Where I was working in the shipyard, they gave me a one-year deferment. So, my son was five months old before I went to Fort McClellan, Ala., where I was for 17 weeks before I went overseas.

Q: Where were you assigned?

A: I went from here over to England and landed on May 20, 1944. We stayed there until D-Day, when they took us down to the coast.

Q: What was the mood like during the crossing of the channel, for the Allied Invasion.

A: Well, I went across the English Channel on a Liberty Ship, and I just prayed to God the whole time that we had built them good, because that thing was bouncing up and down like a rubber ball.

Q: What was it like to be part of the Allied invasion?

A: Oh, I just thank God I didn’t have to go in on the first wave. I went on the fourth wave and landed on Omaha Beach. The beaches had been cleared by then and I think we were five miles inland at that time, which was good.

Q: What did you do when you landed?

A: We were loading ammunition at night to go up to the front. Then this lieutenant came down from the 2nd Infantry Division and said they needed five replacements because of casualties, so they took us up to the front. I went to Headquarters Company, which was about 1,000 yards behind the front line. From there I fought through Normandy, through all the hedgerows. That was a tough battle. We were gaining yards instead of miles.  

Q: Did you have any particularly close calls?

A: One day I came around a corner and I looked up this row of hedgerows and there was a German tank facing right down at me. I jumped over that hedgerow and right into this ready-made foxhole, where there was a German. I was about to shoot him when I found out he was already dead – I could tell by the blood on him. I could hear the thud hitting the hedgerow from the tank behind us. So, me and that German slept there all night long.

Q: I take it you were able to rejoin your unit?

A: Yes, and we finally ended up in the Ardennes Forest. We held a position there for almost a month, while the rest of the line in back of us was catching up. Finally, they gave us orders that we were going to move out. They took us about a mile behind the lines and we saw all these men from the 99th coming back. We just assumed that we were going to take their positions. Come to find out, the Germans had overrun them and we were going up to try and fill in where they were losing.

Q: That must have been disheartening, knowing you were going in on the losing end like that. Did you jump right on the front line?

A: No. They took us up to this wooded area where our lieutenant said, “We’ll stay here for the night and check our position in the morning.” It was about six o’clock the next morning when all hell broke loose from small arms fire. The lieutenant came to me, because my job at the time was to drive the radio jeep, and said, “Howard, we’ve got to go out to the next town and find out what the 99th positions are.” So, I unzipped my sleeping bag and snow fell in on me – it had snowed two inches that night.

Q: Were you able to get info you needed on troop positions?

A: No, there were no positions. We found the command post in a church rectory, but the only person there was this captain sitting alone at a desk. My lieutenant asked if he could tell us what the positions were for his troops. He had his head in his hands and said, “I don’t know. About two hours ago I gave, ‘Every Man for Himself.’ My lieutenant turned to me and said, “Howard, let’s get the hell out of here.”

Q: What did you do then?

A: We went back two miles to our outfit. We set up out own front line and stayed there about 24 hours, and then the Germans started to overrun us. They backed us up twice. We finally ended up in Krinklet, Belgium. We started to get surrounded – we got surrounded on three sides – when, fortunately, our battalion commander found an opening he thought we could squeeze through and get to Elsenborn Ridge, which was the highest spot in that area. Some of the boys were using hand grenades to break the frost in the land so they could dig their trenches. But we set up our outfit and the Germans tried four days in a row to overcome us, and we held. This captured colonel said to our commander, “We tried for four days to try and break trough but we hit a brick wall and that brick wall was the 2nd Division.”

Q: What was it like to be a part of the Battle of the Bulge?

A: Oh, my Lord. That was the worst part of the war because you were also fighting the elements. It was zero weather most of the time and snow one or two feet deep, and, of course, you’re fighting the Germans every day. It was bad – very bad. We lost a lot of men, and they lost a lot of men.

Q: What was the mood of your fellow soldiers during the battle?

A: Well, they knew they were fighting for their lives, because it was either them or us at that particular time.

Q: How were you personally able to hold up during those four days of life-or-death fighting?

A: I don’t know. It’s hard to say. I was scared like hell, I’ll tell you that.

Q: What was daily life like, in between the battles?

A: Well, there weren’t many steak dinners, I’ll tell you that. It was all powdered milk and powdered eggs and powdered Spam, too, I’d imagine.

Q: During that hard winter, was there anything that gave you comfort – letters from home, maybe Christmas packages?

A: We didn’t even know it was Christmas. But then they said, “If you want to go to church, there’s a barn about 100 yards back. Take four or five men at a time and crawl up the ditch and get into the barn.” We found a priest there and he had set up two bales of hay with a white cloth over the top and a chalice on top of that. So, we made our church on Christmas day and that was great as I was a Catholic.

Q: I’ve read you freed a group of POWs. How did that happen?

A: After we cleared out Duderstadt, Germany, on the way out, at the end of town, I said, “I’ll be a son-of-a-gun, there’s a prisoner-of-war camp!” We saw all these men through this wire fence, but they didn’t dare to come out because they thought the Germans were still there. I unlocked the gate and I hollered to the guys, I said, “We’re American soldiers, you men are free!” Well, all hell broke loose. The men came running out, giving us hugs and shaking our hands and everything, some looking for smokes. This one guy came up to me and said, “Sir, can I have your address in the USA?” I said, “I’ll give you my address if you’ll write and tell my wife that I’m OK.” Well, he went and wrote a beautiful letter to my wife, which I still have. His name was Sgt. Harry Richardson, from the Imperial Forces in Australia.

Q: Did you ever meet Sgt. Richardson after the war?

A: No, never again, but he kept his promise. I thought it was very nice of him to remember. He said, “I saw your husband, he even looked well-shaven. He looks like he’s in good shape.” He said, “I hope nothing happens to these boys, where it’s so close to the end of the war.”

This was on April 12. Ironically, on the 17th I was wounded in Leipzig, Germany. A shell fragment hit me in the leg and something hit right here [points to spot a half-inch over his left eye].

Q: How did that happen?

A: This mortar shell came down and hit the road in front of my jeep and went through the windshield. I fell out of the jeep and I must have passed out, because when I’d come to, the medics had taken me to this schoolhouse that they had made into a first aid station.

Q: You must have felt lucky to be alive.

A: I was relieved in the fact that I wound up in a hospital, where I was safe [laughs]. They flew me to Bar-le-Duc, France. I stayed there for two weeks in the 95th General Hospital and they gave me the Purple Heart while I was there. After I came out I was anxious to get back to my unit, but, while I was in the hospital, fortunately, the war in Europe ended. We were one of the first divisions to leave Europe. Unfortunately, we were going to go to fight Japan.

Q: Did you see action in the Pacific?

A: No. We came back to the States first and they gave us a 30-day furlough. During that time, the war in Japan ended.

Q: What was the feeling like, locally?

A: Everybody came down to Monument Square. It was wild. This girl from the Portland Press Herald came up to me, because I had my uniform on, and she said, “What does this mean to you, with the war ending?” I said, “What would it mean to you if you were going off to fight Japan?”

Q: What did you do after the war?

A: I got a job painting a house out in Rosemont. But on that particular day, it rained. I stood on the corner waiting for the bus to take me back home to Munjoy Hill and, I’ll be a son-of-a-gun, this fellow came along in a pickup truck and he said, “Would you like a ride back to Portland?” I said, “Yes, I’d love it!”

Well, we got to talking and he asked what I did before the war. I said I had worked in the shipyard and before that I had worked in an office as a shipper for one year.

He said, “Well, I sell office supplies and I do need a shipping clerk. Would you be interested?” I said, “Yes, I would.” This was in November 1945. His name was Joe Wigon and he had Wigon Office Supply.

Nov. 19 will be 66 years I’ve been with them. Last year my legs started to run out and I couldn’t travel anymore. So, I told my boss, “I guess I’ll have to retire because I can’t drive anymore on these trips through the country.” She said, “You’re not going to retire. You can use the phone can’t you?” I said, “Yes,” so, she said, “Well, you can call all of your customers every week.”

Q: Why do you keep at it, at your age?

A: Oh, you’ve got to have something to do. You can’t just sit in a rocking chair. I was kind of thankful that she still wanted me to do this. I call from here at home and after I make all my calls, I call and give her all my orders and she has the truck driver deliver them.

Q: What is it that’s kept you at one company all thee years?

A: I don’t know. They’ve just treated me well, I guess. They’ve taken good care of me and my family all through the years.

Q: How has your job changed over the course of 66 years?

A: Five years after I started, the Korean War broke out and two of our salesmen had to go back in the service – they were officers – and, so, Mr. Wigon asked me if I would like to try and sell office supplies. I had a walking route in Portland, right downtown, which was very different then. There was Porteous, Rines Brothers, Filene’s and many, many more.

Q: I imagine you’ve seen a lot of business come and go over the years?

A: I sure have. But there’s a lot that have remained, too. There’s this one customer, Chalmers Insurance Agency, they gave me a clock last year. Right at the bottom it says that I’ve been calling on four generations. Can you imagine? I started calling on the grandfather in 1950. One of the sons was 11 years old when I started going up there, now he’s 72.

Q: Is there any chance you’ll ever retire?

A: [laughs] I suppose a long as I can use the phone I won’t. It keeps me busy.


Fundraising to start on new Cape library


CAPE ELIZABETH — A do-over ordered on the design of a new library for Cape Elizabeth was delivered to town councilors and library trustees in separate meetings Monday, winning the wide approval needed for the project to move on to its next phase.

However, that does not necessarily mean the plan, which unlike the first design retains the old Pond Cove School that now fronts the library, will come to fruition. There has been pushback in recent months to the building's projected $8.5 million price tag, and the next step in the process is to find how much of the money can be raised privately, and how much would have to come from taxpayers.

According to Councilor Jessica Sullivan, who serves as liaison between the council and library trustees, approval of the new design, created by Casaccio Architects of Pennsylvania, clears the way for fundraising to begin as soon as Friday. 

That's when Portland-based fundraising consultant Demont Associates – hired for $30,000 in early September from a pool of six bidders – will circulate survey packets to a list of 50 potential donors and other opinion-makers in town. Sullivan said that if those questionnaires are returned by mid-December, Demont can have a report ready for review by the library's oversight study committee "by early January."

Getting a handle on fundraising possibilities is particularly important, Town Manager Michael McGovern said. The council has set aside $100,000 for up-front work, such as Casaccio’s concept drawings, but it’s the study that will set the bar on what town officials can expect to raise in donations and, by extension, what they’ll have to collect via taxation if the new library is to be built.

Councilors "will need to decide by early summer" how much of the project, if any, to bond, in order to have a referendum question ready for the November 2012 ballot, McGovern said. He cautioned that the $8.5 million estimate – a third of which the library hopes to raise in private donations – does not include the cost of doing that fundraising, or how library services might be maintained during reconstruction.

If donors come forward in a big enough way, and if voters approve a bond, the new library could open as soon as 2014, said McGovern.

The dream of replacing the Thomas Memorial Library has been percolating in Cape Elizabeth since 2007, when a Town Council-appointed study committee commissioned a report by Himmel & Wilson Library Consultants, of Milton, Wis. That report outlined a list of 102 structural and design deficiencies in the building, which is actually an amalgamation of five separate structures, including three one-room schoolhouses, each at least a century old, moved to the site and linked via two connecting annexes.

Problems include many specific to libraries – shelves have to be spaced far apart in the older section, which houses the children’s wing, because the floor will no longer handle the load, while they are too close to meet ADA standards in the newer “Pond Cove” wing, due to cramped quarters. There also are issues with moisture and humidity (neither a friend to books), poor ventilation and lack of facilities to run the wiring required of modern libraries in the computer age.

“Another of the gross inadequacies is that the heating plant and control systems are just completely obsolete,” Library Director Jay Scherma said. “Plus, nothing here was designed with any concept of modern plumbing involved.”

"If this was a school building, it'd be shut down," RuthAnne Haley, chairwoman of the board of trustees, said following Monday's meeting.

Combined, the library’s five buildings contain 15,000 square feet of space, but only 13,500 is what Sherma terms “usable,” due to the maze-like result of how the old schoolhouses were cobbled together. “Even at that, the building is about 6,000 square feet too small,” Sherma said.

The Himmel & Wilson report concluded that the cost of renovating any part of the existing library is too great and the historical significance of the component pieces too low, to justify saving the structure. Consequently, Casaccio's original design, presented to focus groups in June, was a complete rebuild, which clocked in at 23,000 square feet.

Lee Casaccio said the concept of his firm’s initial design, crafted after an architectural tour of the town, was “a lighthouse of the mind.” However, some folks felt the “reverse dormers” were a bit too funky for Cape Elizabeth.

“We heard comments from some of our citizens that they were concerned about the first concept, that it lost the Colonial feel that fits in with the rest of the town,” explained Haley, adding that the new plan retains the section of the library that fronts Scott Dyer Road, built in 1910 as the Pond Cove School.

That request of Casaccio was made partly for historical preservation, and partly to reduce costs, she said. Although $8 million was the figure previously bandied about, when anyone felt brave enough to give a dollar figure at all, the current best guess, given the early stage of the project is $8.5 million, which McGovern now claims shaves “about $1 million” off a complete rebuild.

Haley said another concern raised by some was the footprint of the original design. Although the one-story plan left space for 80 parking spots, it crowded both the street frontage and the adjacent grade school. By making the new plan a two-story structure, she said, it preserves the front lawn (where a performance space may be added) and a buffer zone between the library and the school. However, McGovern noted that the new layout leaves room enough for just 50 parking spots.

In order to match up correctly with the old Pond Cove section, the lower floor of the new library will be sunk several feet into the ground. Patrons coming through the new front door will first have to descend “seven or eight steps” to that lower section, which will contain meeting rooms, storage, mechanical rooms and space for the Historical Society, or a few steps up, to the collection.

The Pond Cove building will house the children’s section, while the primary collection, and the young adult section will all be contained in a new wing behind the school.

The roof over the main section will have three traditional dormers on each side of a hipped roof.

“When Jay [Sherma] and I first saw that, we though ‘money,’” joked McGovern, but all of the citizens who have seen it have really liked that part of the plan.

“We’ve really tried to get a lot of input over the last few months from a lot of different folks,” said McGovern, “and, every time we look at a new plan [based on those comments] the staff thinks we’re getting closer and closer to getting it right.”

Sherma admits the drive to grow the library is “not population driven,” as was the most recent expansion in 1987. Instead, even as technology would seem to argue away the need for a larger library, Sherma said the real trend is for libraries to fill a need as community centers for arts and civic functions of all kinds.

“A library is not just a place to store books,” he said, “it is a place where people come together.”