Pages

Thursday, November 10, 2011

Cape council discusses charter change proposal


Debate centers on exemption that allows councilors to serve as firefighters.

CAPE ELIZABETH — Cape Elizabeth Town Councilor Caitlin Jordan got something of a shock two years ago, the day after winning election to her first term.

Jordan works at Alewives Brook Farm, a family-run operation on Old Ocean House Road, and also puts her law degree to use operating The Farmer’s Daughter Legal Services. However, in the winter months, a significant part of her income comes from substitute teaching. At least it did until she became a town councilor.

“The day after I was elected I got locked out of the computer system,” recalled Jordan. “The school essentially fired me.”

The reason is contained in the town charter, which bars “any full- or part-time employee of the town or school department” from serving in a local, elected office. By taking her seat, Jordan lost her job.

At a special workshop session of the Town Council on Monday – held 44 years to the day after adoption of the charter on Nov. 7, 1967 – Jordan asked her peers to consider an amendment to that provision of the charter. After all, she said, the charter does allow firefighters to sit on the council, and firefighters are paid on a per diem basis very similar to that of substitute teachers. Both are issued a W-2, both are covered by Social Security or Maine Retirement, both have Medicare deductions and are covered by workers compensation. Also, while firefighters once got a very nominal stipend, today the wages are much more competitive when on the job.

Jordan’s proposal sparked a debate regarding what it takes for an issue to rise to the level of a charter change, and a discussion reliving the town political history that led to the firefighter exemption in the first place. Ultimately, the council agreed to table the idea and take it up again after Election Day, when the new council, fated to have one new member, is constituted.

“I agree with you, it is inconsistent,” said Chairman David Sherman told Jordan of the firefighter exemption. “But I’m not inclined to go though all the time and energy of a charter change to pursue something that’s not a top priority of the town.”

The majority of the board felt the same way, with only Councilor Sara Lennon arguing Jordan’s case. Jordan could simply recuse herself when it comes time to vote on the school budget, Lennon suggested, just as Councilor James Walsh has habitually done, because his wife works for the school department.

The rest of the council, however, found fault in that argument.

“I don’t think we should have councilors who have to recuse themselves,” said Councilor Jessica Sullivan. “People elect us to speak to a broad spectrum issues. Frankly, I’m uncomfortable with any councilor getting any kind of paycheck from the town, in any kind of capacity. I just think there’s a conflict there.”

“My experience has been that people treat you differently when they know you’re on the council,” said Councilor Anne Swift-Kayatta, intimating that some might wield influence unwittingly. “People seem to fear that you have some control over their lives, their budget, their boss or their reputation.”

Sherman said that, rather than create an additional exception for substitute teachers, he would prefer to remove the exemption for firefighters. However, he stuck to his guns, insisting the matter does not rise to the level of crisis required to call a Charter Commission.

“It’s not a broad enough problem,” agreed Swift-Kayatta. “It also would open the door to other people who want to change the charter in other ways. It could open a whole host of issues that wouldn’t be in the town’s interest.”

Cape Elizabeth has amended its charter only twice, in 1987 and 2004. It was at the earlier date that a “Conflict of Interest” clause was added, banning town and school employees from sitting on the council. There were, however, two exceptions. One was for anyone cross-employed at the time, as was Councilor William Jordan Sr., who was paid to drive a plow truck part-time. The other allowed firefighters to run for office.

Town Manager Michael McGovern pointed out that the Cape Elizabeth of 1987 was much different than today. Back then, serving on the volunteer fire department was still part of the social fabric of the town.

“At the time there were a lot of volunteer firefighters, and those were the folks who ran the community,” he explained. “It wasn’t the younger kids we have on the fire department now. They were all Jordans and Murrays.”

And nobody at that time, McGovern said, was about to tell Fire Captain William Jordan Sr. that he had to doff his white hat for good, or else step down from the Town Council after “ 20-odd years.”

“They just wanted to do an exemption,” said McGovern.

After William Jordan’s time, however, the exemption did create problems. McGovern addressed those issues, but purposefully avoided naming names.

“It wasn’t too many years ago that we had a councilor who worked as a volunteer firefighter and there were some issues,” he said. “It was extremely awkward for me to have to deal with potential disciplinary action against a councilor.”

McGovern said today’s fire department is “a totally different animal,” in part because the council recently agreed to create new per diem positions on the rescue unit.

“I would not want councilors today working in the fire department 10 hours a week, because it could undermine the whole organizational structure of the chain of command,” said McGovern.

Despite this, even McGovern shied away from opening the charter to amendment.

“So, you’re just going to let it stand?” asked Jordan. She also observed that, given the usual length of the charter amendment process, she’d likely be out of office before she could personally benefit from any change.

“My whole issue in bringing this up is the fairness of it,” she said.

Jordan offered that, in lieu of actually emending the charter, the council could add definitions for full-, part-time and per diem employees.

Sherman nixed that idea, however, saying it could be perceived as an attempt to “put an end run on the charter.”


Friday, November 4, 2011

Sanford struts stuff in marching band finals

OLD ORCHARD BEACH — “We are not,” said Megan Swenson, pausing to make her point clear, “the stereotypical band-geek people.”

Asked if that means they’re not like the characters on the Fox television program, “Glee,” about 20 students from the Sanford High School marching band answer in unison, “No!” and then trail off into laughter, pointing and giggling at each other, each one realizing they had blurted out an answer without intending it to come across as a chorus.
But if “Glee” is not so much about geeks as it is about different types of people with different backgrounds bonding over a shared interest, then the Sanford students are exactly like those characters.
“It’s like a family atmosphere. We’re just all so close,” said sophomore Victoria Blow
“We bond with each other a lot,” agreed Madison Caron.
On Saturday, all 53 members of the Sanford High School marching band came together to earn a bronze medal at the Maine Band Directors’ Association state finals at Old Orchard Beach High School.
“This was the culmination of 2½ months of really hard work from, at least in my case, a really great group of kids,” said 20-year veteran director Matt Doiron, following the team’s performance. “I was really thrilled with their performance. We have clearly improved every week. That’s the one thing you focus on.”
From mid-August, when the students first gathered at band camp, through rehearsals totaling as many as 20 hours in some weeks, to six Maine Band Directors’ Association competitions – on top of appearances at Friday night football games – the students progressed from learning basic positions to mastering movement while playing selections from “Hadrian’s Wall.”
“It’s a miracle when you think, about how much has been accomplished in just a few short weeks,” said announcer Roger Painchaud, referring to all 12 schools in Saturday’s competition.
Sanford did not post the highest score at the event. In fact, theirs was the lowest overall. But once a school had played a presidential inaugurations, as Sanford did for Barack Obama in 2009, it’s pretty hard to get flustered over a little thing like a number.
“That still hasn’t made us immune to budget cuts, but we’ve been really lucky in that the community has really identified our program as something important, and they do a decent job taking care of us,” says Doiron. “That’s been nice.”
At the events, each band is judged on its own merits against a slate of six criteria, including performances of the drum majors, the color guard and the percussion section, along with the entire band’s mastery of the selected music, the visual impact as the individual players move across the field in unison, and the general effect of the performance. Each category is given a score between 1 and 5 by a team of judges, working from atop the bleachers and on the field. The sum of all six categories generates a score which, in the final event of the season, results in a medal from each band member.
“Up until several years ago, there used to be a winner – first place, second place, and so on,” explained South Portland Band Director Craig Skeffington. “But then we realized that this is more about the performance, so now each band competes against itself, rather than each other.”
Like cheerleading, the marching band is a school activity that has long since progressed from part of the support system for a school’s football team. Today, it’s an activity in its own right.
“Bands don’t just play the school fight song as they march done the field anymore,” said Doiron. “Today, it’s really more of an artistic endeavor.”
That’s partly why Doiron and his fellow band directors prefer to remove the competitive aspect from the state finals.
”You have to be dedicated to do this,” said Kayleigh Verrell-Peters. “You have to really want to do it and everybody has to work together.”
As Sanford took the field for the medal ceremony, with the temperature plumenting and the snow beginning to fall from the first storm of the season, the Sanford students did not seem at all disappointed with their bronze showing. After all, said Verrell-Peters, “This was our best performance so far.”

Thursday, November 3, 2011

City launches winter market


SOUTH PORTLAND — No sooner has South Portland closed on the season on its first farmers market than it gets ready to claim another new initiative.

On Sunday, the city will see the opening of its first winter’s market.

“It’s going to include 11 vendors from the South Portland, Portland and Scarborough summer markets,” said organizer Caitlin Jordan, of Cape Elizabeth’s Alewives Brook Farm. “We’ll have everything from breads to chicken, dairy, pork, grass-fed beef, lamb, chowders, seafood and all the root vegetables.

“We think there’s a lot of potential in South Portland and we’re hoping that moving people inside and giving them the opportunity to eat healthily and locally all winter long will keep the spirit of supporting local farmers going,” said Jordan.

What remains unknown is the fate of the summer market, which ran on Thursdays in Thomas Knight Park. Although it was launched with much fanfare this past July – including an appearance by the market’s self-proclaimed “biggest cheerleader,” Mayor Rosemarie DeAngelis, in a watermelon costume – attendance dropped over the course of the season.

Penny Jordan, of Cape Elizabeth’s Jordan Farm (no relation to Caitlin Jordan), admits there were mitigating factors. “After the first few weeks it seemed like it rained every Thursday,” she said. Still, both woman have begin stumping to have the market moved to Mill Creak Park next spring. The issue, said Caitlin Jordan, is “location, location, location,” and Thomas Knight Park, in the shadow of the Casco Bay Bridge, doesn’t have it. “A lot of people don’t even know where Thomas Knight Park is,” both Jordans said, in separate interviews.

However, the move to new digs may not go smoothly, if at all. De Angelis herself seems opposed to a Mill Creek location.

"You'd have to close off traffic completely, and you'd be right in the face of Hannaford, who's been a great business partner to the city," she said at a recent council meeting. "That's just not smart."

Penny Jordan said there were several factors that hobbled the summer market, in addition to regular Thursday showers. Some older patrons found it a challenge to navigate the cobblestone walk in Thomas Knight Park, construction in the area, the start of which roughly coincided with the drop in attendance, may have discouraged some, while the time-consuming process of navigating necessary changes to city zoning delayed the start of the season until July, which limited the amount of marketing that could be done effectively while also harvesting.

“Farmer’s don’t have a marketing staff,” said Jordan. “They are the marketing staff.”

Still, Jordan said, the primary problem was location, given nothing else in the Bridgeline section of Knightville to funnel people to the area. However, she said, she is willing to look at sites other than Mill Creek Park.

“I think the location was challenging because there wasn’t enough to draw people down there,” Penny Jordan said. “If you can get people moving down the street with other things, they’ll go down there, but not if that’s the only thing. I think the market really, really, really needs to move for next season.”

While challenges may loom for farmers in year two of the South Portland summer markets, both Jordans have high hopes for the winter market.

“People need to recognize that farming doesn't stop in September,” said Penny Jordan. “And it doesn’t stop in December, January, February or March. It just continues all year long.

“People say, oh, there’s no lettuce, but we’ll have broccoli and kale, and root vegetables aren’t a bad thing,” she said, listing squash, carrots, beets, rutabaga, turnip, cooking radishes, garlic, onions and potatoes. “There are all these products. Consumers who are very much local food advocates need to recognize that there’s a whole bunch of produce that farmers are still harvesting and that they have stored. But it’s not about getting one thing all year round. Eating locally does mean learning to eat seasonally.”







A CLOSER LOOK

SOUTH PORTLAND FARMER’S MARKET
South Portland Farmers Market winter hours
When: Sundays 10 a.m. to 2 p.m., starting Nov. 6
Where: South Portland Planning and Development Building, corner of Ocean and Sawyer streets (in what was the gym of the old Hamlin School)

City superintendent awarded state honor


SOUTH PORTLAND — South Portland Superintendent Suzanne Godin has been named Maine’s 2012 Superintendent of the Year from the Maine School Superintendents Association.

Godin received accolades for her focus on student achievement and her ability to generate community support for the city’s schools, the group said.

Godin, who has been superintendent in South Portland since 2007, was selected by a committee of her colleagues, including former award recipients, Maine School Superintendents Association officers, and presidents of Maine’s superintendent regions.

She received the award on Oct. 26 at the Maine School Superintendents Association annual meeting in Augusta.

“I believe this is recognition of the good work our students, teachers, administrators and board have been doing to support achievement in South Portland,” Godin said.

Godin served as assistant superintendent in South Portland before being named superintendent. Prior to that she was a principal in MSAD 51 serving Cumberland and North Yarmouth. She is active in professional associations, currently serving on the Maine School Superintendent’s Association Executive Committee; as president of the Casco Bay Educational Alliance; and, as the legislative liaison for the Cumberland County Superintendent’s Association.

South Portland School Board member Karen Callaghan nominated Godin for the award, calling her an “absolute dynamo.”

“I have never known anyone so knowledgeable about all aspects of education,” said Callaghan, praising Godin for keeping board members, school staff and the community engaged in school improvement.

This was critical during the campaign to get voter support in 2010 for a major renovation and expansion of South Portland High School. That project is expected to go out to bid in December.
“Suzanne’s leadership in the school department, her dedication to the project and her willingness to provide information at all hours and at a moment’s notice were crucial to the passage of the bond measure,” said Jeffrey Selser, the spokesman for the group that backed the project.
Selser said Godin brings the same dedication and professionalism to championing the school district’s budget and educational programs.

Godin said her greatest accomplishment was developing both adult education and preschool programming in South Portland.

“I feel these two programs were in response to community needs. Both are serving populations of our community that are looking to better prepare themselves through education,” she said.
Her greatest challenge, Godin said, is “balancing all of the various needs of the community, the students, the teachers and the financial realities we all are facing right now.”