Pages

Thursday, September 8, 2011

‘He had the deadest eyes’ — Q&A with Michael Tuohey


  
Michael Tuohey, of Scarborough
SCARBOROUGH — A brush with history can happen to anyone, at any time. For Michael Tuohey, 64, of Scarborough, that moment came on Sept. 11, 2001, when, as a customer service agent for U.S. Airways at the Portland International Airport, he checked in Mohamed Atta and Abdulaziz Alomari, two of the 19 terrorists who went on later that morning to hijack four commercial jetliners, flying two into the World Trade Center towers in New York City, one into the Pentagon, in Washington D. C., and a fourth into a Pennsylvania field.

Atta, the reported ringleader of the operation, transferred to American Airlines Flight 11 at Boston’s Logan International Airport and was aboard the first flight to strike its target, the World Trade Center’s North Tower.

On Monday, Tuohey spoke with The Current about his experience, Atta’s seething anger, and what happened in Portland in the moments of the attack.

Q:  What was your position on 9/11?

A: I was a customer service agent. You do different things on different days, but that particular day I happened to be working at the ticket counter, processing passengers as they came in the door – check their bags, check their IDs, ask them the security questions, things like that.

Q: How long had you been working that job?

A: I came up to Portland in 1986, but I’d been working for U.S. Airways since 1967. I worked in Boston for 19 years, before coming up here. I finally got done in 2004, after 37 years. I didn’t want to get done, either. Due to the financial status of the airline industry, U.S. Airways changed the status of Portland from a mainline station to a commuter station. For me to maintain my status as a mainline employee, I would have had to transfer to New York of Philadelphia and take a pay cut. That was not appealing by any stretch of the imagination. So, I decided to retire.

Q: Do you think your job loss was a direct result of 9/11?

A: Oh, God, yeah. See, that’s the story that, for the life of me, I don’t know why a single news organization has never picked that up – the devastation to the airline industry caused as a result of 9/11.

Everybody’s covered the death and the havoc and the horror of it all, but for hundreds and hundreds and thousands of people, maybe a million or more, who either worked for the airlines, or in any of the ancillary businesses that served the airlines – like the meal services, the fuelers, the mechanical people, the car rentals, the hotels – there was an amazing ripple effect because people stopped flying. A lot of those jobs never came back, in part because of the security that came about, which makes it so much more expensive to service the industry these days, and to maintain those jobs.

Q: Do you think we’ve gone overboard with airline security in the post-9/11 world?

A: I’ll never say they’ve gone overboard with security. I hate it when I hear people whining about people who are there to protect their lives. I mean, c’mon, get over yourself. They’re not there to give you a cheap grope. And people say, “Now they’re shaking down my 80-year-old grandmother, does she look like a terrorist?” and I say, “You tell me what a terrorist looks like.” They’re strapping bombs to 18-year-old girls and sending them out into the marketplace. It could be anybody.

Q: Going back to that day, on the subject of “What does a terrorist look like?” – did you get and danger signals from Atta and Alomari?

A: I got an uneasy feeling. My stomach gave a little “Ugh,” but it wasn’t anything actionable.

Q: What made you uneasy?

A: Well, this guy, Atta, just had the look of a cold, dead person. He had the deadest eyes. At the time I just thought, here’s a guy in a bad mood, because it’s 5:30 in the morning and he’s running late for his flight and, unlike me, he’s not being paid to be pleasant.

Q: Was there anything unusual about their appearance or demeanor?

A: Well, they had these $2,400, first-class tickets to L.A. That was highly unusual. You’re used to seeing $300-$400 tickets that don’t even really cover the cost of transporting people. At this time I just thought it was a good thing to see, because it meant at least somebody was paying money for a ticket.

Q: So, that didn’t raise any concern?

A: No, I was on my way to a smoke break when I saw them standing there looking confused, so I waved them over and just tried to hurry up with the transaction so I could get to my smoke. I scanned the ticket quickly – this took about three seconds, so I didn’t linger over the price very long – and began to process them.

They came up in the system as a “positive bag match,” because they came in real close to flight time. That just meant that the bags could not go on board until they were physically on the plane. At the time the big concern was that somebody would give you a bag and just walk away. The thinking back then was that somebody was not going to blow themselves up.

Q: What happened next?

A: Well, after I tagged their bags I went through the security questions. The younger guy shook his head no to everything, just like he was supposed to, although, today, I don’t know if he really understood anything I said. But, he gave the correct response. Meanwhile, Atta was just smirking – I mean, he had this thing where he’d look at you out of the corner of his eye, just smirking. When he gave me his ID, I looked at it a moment and thought to myself, “Man, if this doesn’t look like an Arab terrorist, nobody does?”

Q: You actually thought that?

A: Oh, yes. That was my exact thought. I mean, you’ve seen his picture. This man was death warmed over. But I quickly corrected myself. I thought, “Hey, that’s not nice. You shouldn’t be stereotyping people.” Again, I mostly just thought he was just an Arab business guy who got up on the wrong side of the bed and was in a bad mood.

Q: So, there was no reason to challenge him at all, then?

A: No, but I did make it a bit harder on him. There was a policy the airlines had recently instituted that allowed passengers to check in once at the beginning of their trip and get all their boarding cards. It didn’t matter if they were transferring airlines, or in what city, as long as every transfer happened within a certain time period, all the boarding cards came out of the system at once.

I never liked that policy. I thought it was bad security because it meant people only had to face airline staff once, no matter where they were going. It may have been convenient for passengers, but I thought it was a hole in security. I mean, how much of a hassle is it to have to show your ID again with another agent [at each transfer], right?

So, I handed them their stuff back and he [Atta] looks it over and noticed I didn’t give him all of his boarding passes. He says, “They told me one-step check in.”

I’m like, geesh, he knows I’m supposed to give him all of his boarding passes. He probably knows I have them. So, I told him, “Mr. Atta, you’re a first-class passenger. I’m sure they’ll be very happy to take care of you at the Admiral’s Club, in Boston.”

He just stared at me and said again, “They told me one-step check-in.” At this point we’re giving each other the hairy eyeball – he knows I’ve got the cards, and I know I’m not giving them to him.

Q: Why did you not want to give him his boarding cards?

A: I didn’t know him. I mean, if he was a frequent traveler. If he was traveling with a family of six, if he was someone I was familiar with. But, I’m like, I don’t know him. Plus, I didn’t like his attitude. He acted like it was demeaning to him to have to deal with me. That was the impression I got. He was just a guy with a bad attitude.

So, I was supposed to give the cards to him, but I just wasn’t comfortable. To me, they were skirting a security point, because, by getting everything from me, they didn’t have to talk to a single airline agent in Boston.

But I didn’t think I was inconveniencing them too much. They were first-class passengers. They could have just gone to the Club, sat down, had a drink, and somebody would have taken care of them.

So, I tried to think on my feet and told him, “Look, Mr. Atta, if you don’t get upstairs to the gate, it’s very likely you’re going to miss you flight altogether.”

Keep in mind, this all happened in a matter of, like, 20 seconds, even with the mutual staring. Finally, he said something in Arabic to the other guy and they walked away.

Then, history takes over from there.

Q: So, he had to go through another security point after leaving you.

A: He had to stop somewhere and get another boarding card to L.A. I think the reason he was so adamant on getting everything from me is that they had rehearsed this. They had rehearsed the whole trip before, I’m sure of it. They knew they could get all of their boarding passes in Portland, which achieved their objective of not all arriving in Boston together.

But, I threw a wrinkle into the plan, and it was like, “Uh-oh, this jerk, this infidel, is not playing like it had always gone before.”

Q: Were you still at work when you found out what they had done?

A: Yeah. It wasn’t a busy day and I had mentioned to some others the incident. I said, “Man, this Arab guy, he wasn’t happy with me. I sure was hoping he wasn’t going to give me a bad time.” And we had a laugh about that, you know?

But then, a couple hours later, there was this girl getting off work from Continental and as she was walking by our counter she said, “Did you hear about the plane crash in New York?” She told us a plane crashed into the World Trade Center, and when I heard that I was thinking maybe a little single-engine, or maybe a helicopter. I don’t think anybody thought on the first reports that it was a commercial airliner.

But, we had a TV in the back and people started to watch. Eventually, someone came out and said it was a commercial airliner and then, shortly after that, someone shouted, “Another one just crashed into the other building.”

My first thought at that was, “terrorists,” and then this girl, Diane, she said, “Tuohey, it was those guys that you checked in this morning. They transferred to American Airlines. It was them, I know it was.”

I was like, “No, those poor guys are dead.” But then it dawned on me – pissed-off Arab guy who looked at me like I was the biggest piece of dung he’d ever seen in his entire life, Holy Jesus, he was a terrorist. But then I was like, how did they do it?

Of course, it was about then that all heck broke loose and they shut down the country.

Q: What was it like in the terminal at that point?

A: Initially, it was ridiculous. There were people screaming at me – “Hey. I got to get my flight!” I tried to tell them, “The air corridors are all shut down.”

“Well, when can you get me out of here,” they’d say. I’m like, “I don’t know. What can I tell you, the president just grounded every place in the United States of America.”

Of course, we began to hear about the other crashes and it was like, “How many of these things are going to happen? Are there some out west, or international flights on their way over?”

Things got backed up a little bit until we convinced people that they might as well go home, that there were no flights coming in, no flights going out, and we had no information about when the skies were going to open again.

It took some doing to get through to some people that we were under attack by a foreign entity.

Q: Was there any sense of danger at the airport?

A: No, not really. We knew we weren’t a target. They wouldn’t have done enough damage crashing into the airport, other than killing everybody on the plane.

Basically, once people cleared out, we were glued to the television. Finally, Diane said to me, we’ve got to call the FBI. By that time, I had already made out copies of all their information, because I knew this was going to be stuff somebody’d want – that they’d paid for their tickets with an American Express card on such-and-such a date, at such-and-such a location – so they could trace it back.

Q: When did you first speak to the FBI?

A: That same day. With everything shut down and more than enough staff, I ended up going home around noon. I was off at 12:30 anyway. I was watching all the stuff on television when the phone rang and I was told, “The FBI’s here. They want to interview you.” So, I went back over to the airport until 8 o’clock that night.

Q: Wow, they debriefed you for that long? What was that like?

A: Oh, it wasn’t too bad. I told them there was a camera right over my head, you can get the whole conversation and get a good look at them. Turns out the camera wasn’t working. So, then, I had to stick around and look at the footage of the camera from where people went through security into the boarding area. It was not a digital system, so that took awhile.

Other than that, it was just a matter of telling them the same story I’ve just told you. Then I went home, slept like a rock, because I’d been up since 3 in the morning. Then I got up the next day and went to work all over again, although, of course, there wasn’t much to do.

Q: Did you testify before the 9/11 Commission?

A: Yeah. I went to a hotel in downtown Portland and was interviewed over the telephone from a couple of hours. I just gave the same story.

Finally, they said, “Mike, is there anything we can do to make security better?” I said, “Yeah, but you’re not going to like my answer.”

Q: Which was?

A: I said, “You’ve got to start profiling people.” I mean, not overtly, not to the point where who are pulling out always just one type of person. But you’ve go to profile, and do what they’ve done in Israel and Europe for years, which is interviews – anyone who doesn’t seem right, you question them pretty intensely.

Q: Do you think what’s happening now with the TSA, what people are objecting to so much, is that being done because of a reluctance to profile people?

A: Oh, God, yes.

Q: Is there anything that could have been done that day to prevent the 9/11 attacks?

A: No, I don’t think anything could have been done that day. What angers me is that, as time goes by, we keep finding out how much the government was aware of, but failed to act on. They should have put us on a heightened level of security. But, of course, that would have slowed things way down.

Q: Could something like 9/11 happen again today?

A: No. Because of the security, but also the attitude of passengers. We are no longer sheep anymore. It used to be that we were like, “Just do what they want. If someone hijacks the plane they are going to set it down somewhere and make a bunch of demands. Eventually, they’ll give up the plane.” It was like, “Just don’t agitate the situation.”

But those days are gone, of people just passively waiting out the situation. People won’t stand for it. They know they might be putting their own lives in danger, but, by doing so, they could be savings so many more lives on the ground.

I don’t think terrorists will ever get access to a cockpit again.



Q&A with George Schuman: Cape man had close ties to twin towers



George Schuman of Cape Elizabeth.
CAPE ELIZABETH — Lady Luck has smiled at least twice upon George Schuman of Cape Elizabeth, who just missed being present for both terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center in New York City.

A consulting architect for the Port Authority of New York/New Jersey, Schuman was on his way to the building for a meeting on Feb. 26, 1993, and had he been just 20 minutes earlier, he would have been in underground parking garage when a truck bomb went off there in an attempt to topple the buildings. Then, on Sept. 11, 2001, a miscommunication had him in Maine for a doctor’s appointment that was not actually scheduled for that day. Had he realized the error in time, Shuman would have been in his office on the 76th floor of 1 World Trade Center on the day of the attack, when American Airlines Flight 11 plowed into the building between the 93rd and 99th floors.

Schuman rushed down to ground zero two days later and helped to guide rescue crews, given his intimate knowledge of the site design and the toxic chemicals rescuers could expect to encounter.

Recently, Schuman took the time to recount his experiences on that fateful day – the first time, he says, that he has done so for the media.

Q: Tell us about yourself, how did you come to live in Maine while working in New York?

A: I’m from New Jersey, but I had family that lived in Oxford County and I just loved it up here. Once I got my degree at the Pratt Institute I tried to come up to Maine, but the economic picture wasn’t that good. I wound up in Texas instead. But, eventually, I found a way to buy a house in Maine while working as a consulting architect and then senior project manager for the Port Authority of New York/New Jersey. I went down there because I couldn’t make a living here and I had to make enough money to pay for college for my two children. I figured if I could make New York money and bring it to Maine, that would help. So, I worked there during the week and came home to Cape Elizabeth every weekend but one in 11 years.

Q: What did you do for the Port Authority?

A: I worked as only a consultant until the last year, when they finally hired me. At the time, they, like most industry, hired temporarily before they’d hire permanently. Senior project manager was my title. Basically, I had responsibility to organize teams of designers and engineers to deal with the public and all of the codes. I had projects on every one of the facilities. I was headquartered on the 76th floor of tower one [the North Tower, or 1 World Trade Center].

Q: When did you first hear about the attacks of 9/11?

A: I was getting in my car, getting ready to go to work. I started to go down, but then turned around because, when I called in on an emergency line – one of the main reasons I called was just to see if people were still alive – they said not to come down because of the nature of the chaos and the destruction. I finally went down two days later. In spite of the fact that they said not to, I went down anyway, because I wanted to do something to help.

Q: Did you have any trouble getting to ground zero?

A: I had no trouble getting into the city. I had working relationships and I had the right credentials to pass through the military checkpoints and the police and all of that. 

Q: What was your first impression of the site?

A: The first impression was the militarization. There were 10 city blocks condoned off and every investigative body imaginable was there. It was like a military siege.  Then when I saw the site itself, since I knew every square inch of he building, almost, I was surprised at how uniformly the floors collapsed on each other. It almost looked like what I’ve seen at controlled explosions.

The unbelievable aspect of it was, even though, as we all know there were very few survivors, there really wasn’t a vestige of anything. Furniture, paper, ductwork, it was all pulverized beyond belief. I’ve seen building collapses in my career before, but it was shocking to not even see pieces of paper. I was just pulverized and, of course, on fire. It was on fire for almost a month and a half. Command posts were set up in the adjacent areas, in any building available, and every single day that I was on site, I’d have to get a new pair of shoes, because my shoes would literally melt, because once you were in the building it was just devastatingly hot.

Q: For those whose only memory of 9/11 is seeing it on TV, can you describe the sensation of actually being at ground zero – the smells and sounds?

A: Oh, the smell of it.  There was nothing but black smoke and toxins. It smelled like burning tires, which of course it was, because so many cars had been on fire. It was just intensely hot; you couldn’t even get close to potions of the site. Then there was the smell of the water impregnated with kerosene and who knows what else. It smelled like a chemical cesspool, really.

But one thing, it wasn’t as chaotic as you might think. Maybe that’s because I was not there until two days after it happened, or maybe it was because everyone was united in a common goal. I mean, everyone was there because they wanted to be there and they were tenacious. It was controlled chaos in a way and it was very visceral.

George Schuman, of Cape Elizabeth, worked for the Port
Authority of New York and New Jersey in 2001. Following
the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, he went to ground
zero to assist with the search for survivors and clean-up
 of the site. (Courtesy photo)
Q: What did you do when you first arrived?

A: Because we were so short staffed, I reported directly to the chief engineer who was in charge of all projects in the Port Authority. He needed to know, still, even after three days of looking for survivors, what was going on. So, I went into a tunnel the very first hour after I got there, because it hadn’t been checked out yet and there was concern there might be somebody in there – actually, at first there was word there might be a train trapped in there. There was none, it was in the PATH (Port Authority Trans-Hudson) station and had been emptied out.  But anyway, I went in there still dressed in a three-piece suit and I got to the middle of the tunnel and couldn’t go any further because the height of the water was rising to the ledges I was walking on.

Q: What was it like being in that tunnel?

A: Oh, I almost died at that point of asphyxiation. I went in all alone to conduct an examination. It was it was a very dumb thing to do, very dumb, I admit it. But there was word there might be some people there, or some bodies. This is a massive system to examine and nobody had gone in yet to this area.

Q: What did you do after that?

A: Mostly, I advised rescue teams on structural integrity problems, because, obviously, the ceiling structures were down – there was bent steel and flaming cars and all of those things. They didn’t know the best way in and out of the lower levels and, of course, I knew the layout intimately.

Q: What was left of the buildings to go into?

The sub-levels, where the PATH train was. And, while it’s true the building was reduced to only about 12 floors of heaped material, there were areas, caverns, so you could actually get into the areas below the mezzanine, which was the first area above [ground]. A lot of inspection had been done in the two days before I got there, looking for people, and they had marked vehicles. But there will so many doors and places and mechanical rooms. 

Q: And you advised rescue crews of what to look for?

A: Yes. The buildings, as you know, had all kinds of hazardous materials. There were three of four hundred pounds of air conditioning refrigerant and, when that’s heated, it turns to poisonous gas. What I was able to do, because I had worked in what they called the materials laboratory for two years there, was to help access and work particularly with the fire department to let them know what to expect. Obviously, they are savvy people, but they did not know what was where.

Q: And you actually led rescue crews into the sub-levels of the World Trade Center? What was that like?

A: How can I describe it? Frankly, I thought I’d be scared to death, but I wasn’t. Maybe I was in shock, or something like that, because the one thing I could think about was to use my skills and knowledge to do something. The fire department, the rescue agencies, FEMA, in a way, I was able to lend them my personal knowledge of the building itself. But it was frightening, with the heat, the smell, the stress, not knowing if something above you was going to collapse. When we had to walk into water the first time through a PATH tunnel, there was concern of it having become highly corrosive from the chemicals dumped into it, so we had to suit up in hazmat suits and breathing apparatus.

Q: Where you ever able to lead a team to a rescue?

A: I never did. I never even saw a body there. It was just too devastating. It was what you would expect to see in a war. But I did not go in all that often. A lot of what I did was just to give information to the command structure, to relay to the rescue teams who were looking for groups of survivors.

But I did go into the tunnels quite often under the Hudson River. The whole basement, which was like eight stories down, was filling with water from the river. The walls were these great, thick slurry walls 24-feet thick, and they had cracks. So, one of the primary things, just to keep other buildings and other streets around it [the World Trade Center] from being undermined was to stabilize that, so a lot of effort when into determining the condition.

On the other end, in New Jersey, it was felt that if there was a catastrophic collapse of one of those tunnels, it would be like squishing water through a straw and it would come out the other end and inundate New Jersey buildings and the PATH systems. So, we built an 8-foot-thick cement wall to seal off the tunnel. That was considered a high-priority job at the time, so I was the manager for that, to make sure it got done.

Q: Have you experienced any ill effects of your exposure to ground zero?

A: I did for the first couple of years. Like many people who were in and around the area, I had skin lesions. I went to one of the foremost doctors in New York, because I was concerned about it, obviously. I don’t know if he played dumb about it or not, but he was like, I don’t know what’s going on. I had trouble getting really getting information about really the health effects. They did go away, eventually.

Q: How long did you remain at ground zero?

A: I was there for two months and then I cashed it in – got out of town. I wanted to be home with my family, so I opened my own business up here.

Q: Did you know any of the people killed in the attack?

A: Oh, yes, I spent two months going to one and two funerals every day, because I knew these people on a professional basis. There were 10,000 people who worked for the Port Authority and there were something like almost 1,000 architects and engineers located in the general area where I worked. Many of them got out, but I’d say 10 to 20 percent didn’t.

Q: Not to ask an insensitive question, but do you ever experience post-traumatic stress?

A: Constantly. And I didn’t experience anything in comparison even close to what so many other people did. But I constantly think about it. I’ll never forget it.

Q: What are the indelible images that stick with you?

A: Probably one I never experienced personally, but one that seems too real from how it was described to me. Many of my closest friends who were making their exit talk of the firemen struggling with their hoses – going up, and up, and up – while they were going down, and they just knew, these people tell me, they just knew that those lives were in a tenuous position, that they probably would not make it back down. And from the looks on the faces of those firefighters, they knew it, too, but on they went. Many of my friends tell me the one remaining thing they think about is those firemen and other rescue workers.

But I want to tell you about the best part of it all.

Q: Please, what was that?

A: The best part – I have never felt such a feeling of community, of nationalism I guess you’d call it, but in the best sense of the word – of people driving in truckloads and truckloads of protective clothing, of people from the south coming up with their barbeque trucks and staying there for two months, feeding people for free. There was so much support, so much harmony. I had never felt anything quite like it. My words fail me because it was such a strong, positive response to such a hideous action. It was like brothers and sisters, like the best part of the ‘60s feeling of, “Hey man, were all in this together.”
I’m not a religious person, but that was the most spiritual moment I’ve ever experienced in my life, to feel that sense of interconnectivity.

Q: What do you think are the great lessons of 9/11?

A: Well, I think we learned some things from the first attack on the World Trade Center. After that we installed positive pressure units in the stairwells that cleared them of smoke and, I think, saved a lot of lives on 9/11. I mean, in that first attack, people were just passing out in the stairwells from the fumes. But what have we learned from 9/11. Well, we’ve infringed on a lot of personal liberties with the Patriot Act and the like, that’s as bad now as it ever was, but, meanwhile, all of our critical facilities – our nuclear reactors, chemical plants, train stations, refineries – nothing was done about that, they’re still as vulnerable as they’ve always been.

Q: And on Sept. 11, what would you like people to think about, during the moment of silence certain to occur at memorial services across the nation?

A: I can easily sum that up and say personal responsibility. For a while there, people were kind of on the lookout for suspicious characters and all. It’s taking that and going one step further and realizing that we really are a global village, that by looking out for you I’m looking out for me. There’s no stronger defense against any terror problem.

If only people would put side the pettiness and remember the days after 9/11, when we really looked out for each other and cared about each other instead of being so egocentric and concerned about material goods.


Cape to consider changes to rescue department


CAPE ELIZABETH — Once again, talk of change is in the air for Cape Elizabeth Fire and Rescue.

This time, that talk could transform the town’s volunteer rescue service – where EMTs and ambulance drivers are paid on a per-call basis – into a so-called “combination service,” with full-time staff stationed on duty during the day.

“I think we may end up going in the direction all of the towns around us have gone, with per diem staff,” Town Manager Michael McGovern said last week. “I’m thinking that might be a part of next year’s budget.”

This marks the third time in as many years that concerns have been raised about the cost, or service, of Cape’s fire and rescue departments.

Last year, there was talk during budget season on folding local fire and rescue efforts and farming the work out to South Portland. That effort was fairly well squashed, McGovern said, when he was able to show how little Cape Elizabeth pays for such services, compared to surrounding towns.

“If you look at the numbers,” McGovern said in a July interview, “Cape Elizabeth spends $61.35 per capita on fire protection, while South Portland spends $215.61. Why would we want to merge our services to that? What purpose would it serve?”

But now, the debate has turned, once again, from cost, to service. In 2009, McGovern was asked to access how long it takes local rescue units to get on scene, due to concern that call times were creeping in the wrong direction.

“State records showed that Cape Elizabeth has one of the fastest response times in Maine to rescue calls,” McGovern said last week. However, he acknowledged those files record the first appearance of an EMT (Emergency Medical Technician) on the incident scene. Most often, said McGovern, the first EMT to arrive is in actuality a cross-trained municipal police officer. Although cops come equipped with oxygen, defibrillators and first aid “jump kits” in their cruisers, they are unable to transport patients to the hospital.

So, last week, McGovern was asked to run the numbers once again.

“It seems that we are having a delayed response in getting volunteer members to respond,” wrote Councilor Caitlin Jordan, in an email to McGovern. 

“Perhaps we are doing the best we can,” she wrote. “Knowing you reviewed this two years ago, I would be interested to know if we have gotten worse, improved, or stayed the same.”

On Friday, McGovern said he had not yet had a chance to get those numbers, but that he hoped to have them on hand for a Sept. 6 council workshop, at which rescue services will be debated. The workshop was scheduled for after The Current’s deadline.

Jordan’s letter does not say if a particular event prompted her concern. However, in his written response, McGovern notes that, “Of the 2,270 calls in the last five years, in no instance has any delay impacted the actual outcome to the patient.”

In the most recent incident to gain public notice – in which David Aschauer, 58, of Portland, died Aug. 22 during the swim portion of a triathlon to benefit the Cape Elizabeth Land Trust – McGovern said a rescue unit was on scene “within seconds.”

“There were right there when he came out of the water,” he said.

Still, McGovern does acknowledge that, police officers aside, there is “no question that response times are growing for the rescue vehicle to be on site.” Exactly how long that average response time is, and how much it has grown by, are answers McGovern promised to have in time for the Sept. 6 workshop.

The problem, said McGovern, is that while Cape Rescue can boast an official roll call of 46 members, with 30 certified to at least an EMT-basic level, the unit answers, on average, 1.2 calls per day – 422 for the calendar year that ended June 30.

“We generally do not have a problem in the evening,” said McGovern. The issue is during the day, when most of the rescue volunteers are at work outside of town, or attending to other matters of their personal lives.

One additional issue in Cape, McGovern said, is familiar to volunteer fire and rescue units across the state. Young people, it seems, are simply not joining up as fast as older members are retiring.

“We now see a need to call South Portland more often when we do not have enough volunteers respond from Cape Elizabeth,” said McGovern. “We also have to put out a second call for volunteers to respond more often than we have in the past.”