Pages

Thursday, September 1, 2011

Prouts Neck parking plan proceeds


As lawsuit looms, Sprague Corp. submits Scarborough Beach lot project for site review


SCARBOROUGH — That noise you just heard in Scarborough was the sound of the other shoe dropping.

Of course, it wasn’t so much a shoe as a beach sandal, but it fell on the sands off Prouts Neck, and that’s what has so many people worked up.

A beachside development project initiated by the Sprague Corp. – which has triggered an appeal in Cumberland County Superior Court after a decision by the town’s Zoning Board of Appeals allowed it to move to the planning phase – has now been submitted to the town for “peer review.”

“It will add to our costs to have to defend the zoning board decision,” but we’re moving ahead,” Seth Sprague said Tuesday. “We’re quite confident that the decision will be upheld in court.”

Town Planner Dan Bacon said “peer review” is a preliminary process in which a project is reviewed by members of his staff, or professionals retained by the town, allowing them to provide feedback before submission to the Planning Board for site plan review.

The plans came in two weeks ago, said Bacon. Meanwhile, Sprague said he’s hopeful the formal review will begin at the Planning Board’s Sept. 12 meeting.

Based on previous interest, expect that meeting to be well-attended.

On May 11, about 75 people turned out to watch, and in some cases jeer, when Scarborough’s Zoning Board of Appeals allowed a “special exemption” to rural zoning rules that will let Sprague Corp., under subsidiary Black Point Resource Management, build a parking lot for 370 vehicles in a 62-acre field it owns off Black Point Road.

That lot would give the public new access to a 1,700-foot-long swath of Sprague-owned beach, not far from the 2,100-foot-long Scarborough Beach State Park. The park is managed by Sprague Corp., but is separated from the new section by a sliver of private property.

“It’s going to be a big party down there,” said Edith Iler, at the time. Her home is sandwiched between the two Sprague-run sections and, she said, “the shortest way to the beach from the western side of that new parking lot will be right down our driveway and then across our porch.”

The parking-lot project was made possible by a zoning change, enacted by the Town Council in May 2010, that relaxed rules in Scarborough’s “rural farming zone.”

Among a host of changes, those rules created a special exemption for outdoor recreation, described by Bacon as “creative land uses to keep land open, and not developed as new neighborhoods.”

According to Bacon, in the 1970s, Scarborough enacted strict zoning rules for agriculture. In more recent years, as values have shifted, there has been a drive to relax some of those rules, with an eye to keeping land open. Beginning in early 2009, the Comprehensive Plan Implementation Committee (CPIC) began debate on a host of changes, including the right of the zoning appeals board to allow a special exemption from the rules for so-called commercial outdoor recreation.

But the court appeal filed on behalf of abutters by John C. Bannon, of Portland law firm Murray Plumb & Murray, claims the zoning board’s view that Sprague’s parking lot is an outdoor-recreation use, “constitutes an abuse of discretion,” even taking into account other aspects of the project, including, “a few picnic tables, a short walking trail, a boardwalk to the beach [and] a small playground.”

The beach itself – where one might expect to find activity more commonly considered outdoor recreation, and which is the admitted destination of folks who will use the lot, walks, picnic areas and playgrounds – is not in the RF zone. Because it lies in a Resource Protection (RP) zones, the recreation exemption cannot apply to any activity that takes place there.

The appeal by the abutters also claims the special exemption permit failed to meet one of its qualifying criteria, that it would not have an adverse impact on others in the area.

The “use, value and enjoyment of their real property will in fact be adversely affected by the noise, odors, lighting, traffic, stormwater runoff, security, increased fire risk, potential groundwater contamination and general commercial activities.”

However, Bannon (who could not be reached for comment) agreed to have the appeal “held in abeyance” until Sprague submitted his project to the Planning Board.

Town Manager Tom Hall said that may mitigate the suit, which the town “is obligated to defend.”

“I think all sides agree that there are many details that will be flushed out and identified during the site plan process,” said Hall. “After all, it is the Planning Board that is equipped to deal in the minutiae and detail of how a site actually works.”

Still, while the Planning Board may help make peace between Sprague and the site abutters, Sprague said the abeyance mostly helps plaintiffs get two suits for the price of one.

“Whatever happens at the Planning Board, they’ll throw that into their appeal,” he said.

Bacon and Sprague both say that the plan just submitted is “essentially” what the Zoning Board of Appeals saw in May, with its changes added in, including allowed hours of operation, restroom requirements and rules for sightline buffers.

“We’ve done everything that we are able to do to mitigate impacts on neighbors,” said Sprague. “The parking area won’t be visible from any of the homes in the area. You also won’t be able to see it from Black Point Road.

“We even agreed to put a closed-vent system in the concession stand, so there will not even be any odors at all,” said Sprague.

Sprague also must retain use of the current 140-space overflow lot for the state park, across Black Point Road, and cannot apply for additional spots until “two full seasons” have passed.

Despite the hoopla created by Sprague’s proposal, one thing Scarborough can’t do is ignore it, or refuse to review it, even though it knows that, whatever the result, odds are the town will end up tangled in a costly lawsuit.

“That’s not how the process works,” said Hall. “Anyone is entitled to make a proposal as long as their submission meets out requirements.”

For his part, Sprague says that, despite the objections of abutters, he is merely meeting a public need.

“There is clearly a demand for improved access to the water,” he said. “We’re trying to satisfy that demand with a plan we believe really will have a minimal impact on the area.

“The folks who already live down there are clearly opposed to it,” said Sprague, “ but I think once the facility is up and running everyone will find that it will run smoothly and provide a good new amenity for people in the area.”



All eyes on Pine Point condo proposal


Lighthouse Inn, part of controversial 2009 “land swap” with town, back with new project


SCARBOROUGH — One of the most controversial properties in Scarborough is poised to once again pack board meetings.

Nick and Peter Truman, who co-own the Lighthouse Inn at Pine Point, have initiated plans to convert their 22-unit seasonal motel at 366 Pine Point Road into 12 luxury condominiums that would be occupied year round.

This is the same property that, by all estimates, drew "hundreds of people" to Planning Board hearings in 2009, mostly to protest a land-swap between the Trumans and the town. In that deal, Scarborough decommissioned the end of Pine Point Road that ran past the inn and gave it to the Trumans in return for part of an adjacent parking lot, which later became Snowberry Ocean View Park.

The Trumans new project includes the addition of a third story to the building, which sits on a 35,000-square-foot lot (about 3/4 of an acre). According to Town Planner Dan Bacon, the Inn is in as R-4 zone, which permits no more than four housing units per acre.

"Motels are not allowed in that zone, but it's been there since before zoning," said Bacon. "This proposed use would arguably be more conforming than a motel, but 12 units on the amount of land they have still would be nonconforming."

The Trumans submitted the plan to the Planning Board for an "advisory review," an initial step preparatory to review before Scarborough's Zoning Board of Appeals, which has the power to allow the change of use. Essentially, the Planning Board reviews the pitch first, to coach the zoning group on what it should look for when it goes up to bat.

In addition to the change from a non-conforming business to a non-conforming residential unit, the project also may require the zoning board to grant variances from certain setback requirements.

"That's not really clear right now, so the code enforcement officer, on behalf of the Zoning Board of Appeals, has asked for more information," said Bacon. "One thing they are looking for is elevation [drawings] on all four sides."

In order to meet that request, the Trumans pulled their project from an Aug. 22 Planning Board review.  Had it gone forward that night, there were “seven or eight” members of the Pine Point Residents Association ready to monitor the proceedings, said group member Judy Shirk.

Although the association is an “informal group” with “nobody in charge,” Shirk often takes point for the group. She said she and her neighbors are not necessarily fighting the Trumans’ proposal, at least not yet. They just want to be sure the project is appropriate to the neighborhood.

“We’re not opposed to condominiums, or even the zoning change they would need,” she said. “But on less than an acre to have such an enormous building as they seem to want … well, we’re just curious. We don’t really know what all the details are at this point.”

Nicholas Truman said the renovation would not stand out from any of the other three-story condo units already built in the area.

“It’s going to be a first-class project,” he said. “This building is going to look extremely attractive and will broaden the tax base of the town.

“We’ve always run a nice place, with a nice clientele,” said Truman, professing some confusion over reaction to his business. “We’ve been here since 1952. My brother and I have run the place for 30 years. You’d think the neighborhood would be proud of us, but every time we try and do something down here, it’s like we’re trying to put in a nuclear reactor.”

Shirk admits that her group got off the ground in 2005, when the Trumans proposed a similar condo project. That one died on the drawing table, due to the public uproar. The “land-swap” went through only thanks to a last-minute vote switch by Town Councilor Richard Sullivan, who went on to pay the price at the polls, losing his next election.

“People don’t like to see change,” said Truman. “This residents group – and they’re not even direct abutters – they’re a small, vocal group that doesn’t want to see any change. We’re not asking for anything different that what others around us already have.

“I think when this is said and done, it’s going to be like the land swap, where people look at the park they got and they are just thrilled with it. They love it,” said Truman.

“It is pretty, but I wish it hadn’t been done,” said Shirk. “We lost our road. It was more than just a dead-end road. That was a year-round access way to the shore. Now, what we have is a seasonal foot path near the shore that the town doesn’t maintain in the winter.

“It would have been bad enough if the town had sold the road, but it just gave it away,” said Shirk. “We had so much and look at what we have now.

Shirk claims there is plenty of animosity over the land swap deal. Just because the town is no longer hearing complaints, that does not equal love of the result, she said. 

“After they gave the road away, I think a lot of people got tired of it all,” she said. “They just figured, the town is going to do whatever they want to do.

“So, this latest deal, I’m sure it will happen, too, regardless,” Shirk said.

Truman certainly hopes so.

“The ironic thing was that if the last project [in 2005] had got done, they’d still have their street,” he said, noting that longstanding efforts to convert the building to condo units is his way, as a “small businessman” to cash out his business and retire.

If he could have sold out of the Inn in 2005, he would not have needed to try and secure a better business environment with the 2009 land swap, which was all about moving his customer’s parking closer to the inn, he said.

This latest attempt to convert the inn to condos and sell of the units will eliminate the business, conform better to local zoning, and create “the most affordable beach-front property in Scarborough,” said Truman.

“I can guarantee you that when this thing is done, it’s going to be a win for everybody in the community,” he said.

Flyover fallout


Officials say flights over South Portland could end by 2012, but residents remain skeptical


SOUTH PORTLAND — Every South Portlander knows the feeling – the low rumble in the gut, the reverberation in the chest, the echo in the ears – that says a commercial plane has just taken off from Portland International Airport.

But that signal may soon be coming to an end.

On Aug. 18, an Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) official told the Jetport’s Noise Advisory Committee that direct flyovers of South Portland could end as soon as July 27, 2012.

“We have an 18-step process that takes about three months to complete and we will start that on the 31st of this month,” said Jon Harris, a lead air traffic specialist with the FAA’s Boston Center station in Nashua, N.H. “As far as procedures go, what we are going to create is not overly difficulty, conception-wise, design-wise or industry-wise. So, I don’t foresee any major bumps in the road.

“There are a lot of things that have to come together,” said Harris, “but I don’t see any long pole in the tent, so to speak.”

But some residents who have been fighting for years for a change to the flight path say they’ll believe it when they see it. The federal government has little interest in listening to residents, some say, and the noise committee has been ineffectual.

“It just makes a mockery of calling this a noise committee,” said Tom Ainsworth, president of the Stroudwater Village Association, after the meeting.

Jetport Director Paul Bradbury said the procedure on the table would divert more than 90 percent of all air traffic that now passes over the South Portland peninsula. Once approved by the FAA, pilots would be able to fly a RNAV (Radio Navigation) path down the Fore River, following signals to a GPS unit to be built on Hog Island Ledge. That same path, known as the "harbor-view approach" is now used for arrivals at the jetport, but only during the day, under optimal weather conditions.

Bradbury said after the Aug. 18 meeting that the harbor-view approach was used at night until, years ago, a pilot coming up the river toward the jetport reportedly lined up his landing approach to the interstate, rather than the runway.

Harris said he could not write a procedure to once again allow a harbor-view approach in all conditions. Landing approaches, he said, are handled by a different, non-FAA group. He only handles take-offs.

And, while the new procedures can be finalized “by Thanksgiving,” they then have to go to the Aviation Standards National Field Office, in Oklahoma City, Okla.

“We build the procedure,” said Harris, “but, unfortunately, my software and their software, they don’t talk. That’s government at it’s finest. Yes, I know, I’m sorry. But they then have to rebuild what I build for procedures in their language.”

That process, plus industry comment periods, training and testing, map drafting and software updates, takes “about seven months,” said Harris. Still, he said, a “final publication date” of new takeoff procedures for Portland has been reserved “in the pipeline” with the National Air Space Procedures Team for July 26, 2012.

“Everything will be set so they can then take effect the following day,” he said.

At a noise advisory committee meeting in South Portland on May 30, Bradbury seemed to raise the hackles of audience members when he said the jetport first applied to for the new RNAV procedure “almost two years ago.”

Harris said the delay in getting to this point was due to hang-ups with people and product. A new radar-controlling computer system known as ERAM (En Route Automated Modernization) came online, delaying the design of implementation of new flight procedures.

“That was a player in the equation,” said Harris. “The conversion of the Boston center’s radar system has been done on an incremental time-period basis, and there was a formal moratorium issued by FAA in Washington that we would not be inserting new requirements and procedures that would cause changes while they brought the system online. They did not want to add complexity by simultaneously adding new procedures into something that simply needed to get up and get running.”

Also, ongoing contract negotiations between the FAA and the National Air Traffic Controllers Association hung on a provision that “the workforce would have a more active voice in changes,” said Harris. 

By the time contract and computer issues were resolved, Portland was simply shunted to the back of the line, being a smaller market.

“The FAA will listen and be very polite, but, really, they tend to go away from here thinking that Portland really doesn’t have a noise problem, at least compared to other, larger cities,” said Michael Wood, a Scarborough town councilor who holds a supervisory position in the jetport tower.

Despite the apparent good news that takeoffs, at least, could soon be diverted away from the city, there were some angry mutterings from noise committee members and spectators alike.

After Harris left, Ainsworth, of the Stroudwater Village Association, said he had little faith in the noise committee’s ability to affect any real change that bureaucracies from Washington, D.C., to the Portland City Council are not interested in attacking.

“It just makes a mockery of calling this a noise committee,” Ainsworth said. “You don’t even have a noise officer at the airport. This is a mockery. So, I am here to participate in this month’s mockery.”

“Quarterly,” corrected Ed Suslovic, who chairs the committee by virtue of his seat on the Portland City Council.

Later in the meeting, Ainsworth moved to ask the Portland City Council to hire a noise officer, but only South Portland representative Maggie Shaw took his side.

Meanwhile, Paul Ouellette of Portland complained of the health issues, a topic Suslovic refused to broach, even when he agreed that “noise causes health issues.”

Ouellette also faulted the noise committee on its apparent lack of progress.

“Something isn’t working right,” he said. “We’re talking a lot and not a lot is getting done.”

Liz Beausan of South Portland said she doubted that the new RNAV take-off route would have any impact on jet noise in South Portland. Bradbury pointed out that the jetport can “only suggest” an approach path. The pilot has the final say. And although Bradbury said 96 percent of all pilots take the harbor-view approach away from the city when it is offered, Beausang refused to believe that was true, based on her own observation.

“What good is it if it can’t be enforced?” she asked. “It saves them a buck to fly over our houses. We’re home, we see it, and we want you to understand that.”


East Coast quake felt in southern Maine



SOUTHERN MAINE — A magnitude 5.9 earthquake centered in Virginia, strong enough to temporarily close Newark and JFK airports, was felt across southern Maine Tuesday, Aug. 23.

According to the U.S. Geological Survey, the epicenter of the quake, which struck at 1:51 p.m., was 27 miles east of Charlottesville, Va., at a depth of 0.6 miles. The quake was reportedly strong enough to make skyscrapers sway in New York City, knock stones from the façade of the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C., and prompt the evacuation of U.S. Capitol building.

No damage was reported in Maine, although Scarborough police dispatchers reported receiving “a couple of calls.”

For the most part, the temblor played out locally as a did-you-feel-that meme on Twitter, with people reporting ground movement as far north as Andover. Locally, reports were posted on Twitter at both Pine Point, in Scarborough and Willard Beach, in South Portland.

“[It was] a very mild shaking,” reported Kelsey O’Connell. “I was laying out on Willard Beach and felt the ground trembling. Most people didn’t, but my friend and I noticed.”

Rich Obrey, of Gorham, a freelance photographer who often shoots for Current Publishing, provided a typical report.

“I was sitting in my studio, which is a fairly standard structure with a cement floor, and my chair started to wobble,” he said. “I live near the Shaw Brothers gravel pit and thought at first that they might be blasting. I listened for a book, but there was no sound.”

Obrey said it took only a moment to realize what had actually happened when his mother emerged from her 40-foot camper to find out why it was shaking, while his son reported the flat-screen TV “nearly tipped over.”

Maine State Geologist Robert Marvinney said Maine gets “a handful of very small” earthquakes each year, measuring 1 to 2 on the Richter scale. Generally, the scale needs to tip 2.5 to be felt by humans, while it takes a magnitude 4 to create moderate damage.

“On average, we have one magnitude 3 quake every year that can be felt across a fairly wide area in Maine,” said Marvinney. “It’s very hard to understand exactly what cause one of these in a particular place. We have never been able to relate them to an active fault.”

Maine is part of the North American tectonic plate, which extends from the West Coast to the mid-Atlantic. Earthquakes can happen as plates move and snap against one another, with wave motion causing earth movement far from the edges. That, said Marvinney, could be what caused today’s quake.

“Although most activity, and certainly the largest, happens at the ends of plates, the motion waves gel across the entire plate,” he explained.

In Maine and other northern latitude states, quakes sometimes happen as a result of the earth continuing to rebound from the weight of ice-age glaciers.

“Four thousand feet of ice is pretty heavy, so, yes, that is something that is definitely still occurring,” said Marvinney.